Your Patent Won't Save You

November 11, 2026 · James Wang

A patent protects a startup a lot less than most founders think. It gives you the right to sue anyone who uses your invention, and suing is the expensive part, because the patent office doesn’t enforce anything on your behalf. It’s why I say you shouldn’t rely on a patent to save you, since a right you can’t afford to defend is close to useless, and the clearest version of the reason is a piece of advice I heard in the med tech space.

Permission to Sue

When a startup shares its ideas with a large incumbent that wants to “partner,” three things can happen. The incumbent can buy the startup early at a very low valuation, which is probably the best outcome. It can become the startup’s biggest customer, sign a huge contract, and drop it right after the startup has ramped up to meet demand and has no runway left. Or it can take the ideas and designs it was shown and build the product itself. In the last two cases, the incumbent can tell the startup to go ahead and sue, knowing that litigation takes years and the startup has neither the time nor the money.

Say the startup raised $2 million and spends $150,000 a month, to pick some round numbers, so it has a little over a year of runway. A patent suit can take a few years and a few million dollars to get through trial, and the defendant’s usual first move is to challenge whether the patent is valid at all, so the startup has to defend its patent before it ever gets to enforce it. The incumbent pays for all of that out of a legal budget nobody will notice, and the startup would have to spend more than it raised, for longer than it can survive. That’s how the second scenario can end with the incumbent buying the company for pennies on the dollar, patent included.

Four Ways to Own Something

Last Thursday I taught the IP session of my entrepreneurship class at UT Dallas, and I brought in Andrew Lin, Director of Technology at Vela Wood, as a guest. Andrew added a lot of color to the legal questions and then fielded a ton of questions about AI and how it’s changing the practice of law today. My students got all of that for free, which is a pretty good deal considering he bills more per hour than a college kid makes. IP is one of the learning objectives for the class and something every founder needs to understand, so this is exactly the kind of conversation I want my students exposed to.

There are four kinds of IP, and each one has its own price and its own way of going away. Copyright is automatic, so the moment you save your code or your pitch deck you own the expression, but it never covers the idea underneath it. A trademark protects the name customers use to find you. You get local rights just by using it in business, and $350 per class gets you a federal registration, but you can lose it by abandoning it or by letting it become the everyday word for the product, which is what happened to escalator and thermos.

A trade secret is anything valuable because nobody else knows it, and it lasts as long as it stays secret, which can be forever. A patent is the only one of the four you have to apply for. A provisional application costs as little as $65 and locks in your filing date, and then the real application, the examination, and the attorney who writes the claims cost a lot more. In exchange you publish how the invention works, and you get twenty years in which nobody else is allowed to use it without your permission.

The clock on a patent also starts earlier than founders expect. Anything you disclose publicly before filing counts against you, including your own pitch. The U.S. gives you one year from your first public disclosure to file, and Europe and China give you essentially none, so a founder who pitches before filing may have already given up international protection. My students’ final pitches go public at a competition on December 2, so for any team with a real invention, the provisional comes first.

None of this makes patents worthless, though. For hardware and medical device startups they matter a lot, because the invention is physical and a competitor can take the product apart the day it ships. Those founders should file. What I’d tell them is that the patent only starts the protection, and the rest of it is having enough money and time to defend it.

What Software Founders Can Actually Keep

For a software startup the patent question usually answers itself. Since the Supreme Court decided Alice v. CLS Bank in 2014, a known business process done on a computer generally isn’t patentable, and that describes most apps, including most of the ones in my class. What a software company can keep is its secrets and its name, and both are cheap.

The federal Defend Trade Secrets Act only treats information as a trade secret if its owner “has taken reasonable measures to keep such information secret.” So a court asks what you did to keep it, and a codebase every contractor could pull down from GitHub probably doesn’t qualify. The measures are boring… NDAs, access limits, and a checklist for when someone leaves, and they cost almost nothing until the day you need them. Enforcing a trade secret still takes a lawsuit, and Waymo had Google’s legal budget behind it when it got about $245 million out of Uber. I think it’s still the better deal for software, because the parts of a software company worth stealing are the backend, the data, and the process, which are exactly the parts a customer never sees.

The name is the other thing a software company can own, and it’s where my class got its biggest surprise. During the team activity, many of the teams found out their names were already taken. Trademark law protects a name more the less it describes the product. A generic word is never protectable, a descriptive one only after customers learn it means you, and an invented word is protected from the first day. That’s a big part of why so many startups have weird names. Some of it is that the .com for a real word costs a fortune, but the law rewards the strange name too, and the descriptive name that customers understand instantly is the one you’re least able to keep.

So some of my teams have some renaming to do before December 2. A classroom is about the cheapest place to find out your name is taken, since the usual way founders find out is a cease-and-desist letter after they’ve already built a brand on it.