Paxton Fails the Reference Check

October 22, 2026 · James Wang

The most useful thing you can learn about a person is what the people who worked closest to them say when they have no reason to say anything at all. I don’t usually write about politics, and I’m making an exception this week because Texans are voting early in the Senate race between Ken Paxton and James Talarico, and I think this one matters. I’m endorsing Talarico. I’ve been reading Paxton’s record the way an investor reads a founder’s, and I don’t think it clears the bar, and I don’t believe he represents what most Texans actually believe in.

How Back Channels Work

When a founder raises a round, they hand investors a list of references, and every name on that list will say nice things, because the founder picked them. So investors go around the list. They call the former cofounder, the early employee who left, the lawyer who used to handle the company’s work. Those calls take time and they’re awkward, and they’re the ones that find problems, because a former colleague has nothing to gain from talking and something to lose. The strongest negative signal in that process comes from someone who was on the founder’s side, was paid to be there, and chose to walk away.

Paxton’s back channel is unusually loud. David Maxwell, a longtime Texas Ranger, was his Director of Law Enforcement. In 2020, Maxwell and other senior deputies told the FBI they believed Paxton was using his office to help Nate Paul, an Austin real estate developer and political donor. Four of them were fired, Maxwell included, and they sued under the Texas Whistleblower Act. Maxwell has since endorsed Talarico. So has Dan Cogdell, who represented Paxton for nearly a decade in both his securities fraud case and his impeachment trial, and who said his former client “has lost sight of his core mission.” Cogdell also says the impeachment acquittal was right and that he doesn’t dislike Paxton personally, which makes his endorsement harder to dismiss as a grudge.

Read the Judgment

The whistleblower case is the document I’d read first. In February 2023, Paxton agreed to settle with the four former deputies for $3.3 million and asked the Legislature to pay it out of public funds. That request is what prompted the Texas House to investigate him, and the investigation is what led to his impeachment. Paxton later said he would no longer contest the facts of the case. In April 2025, a Travis County judge ruled that the employees had proven his office violated the whistleblower law, and the judgment came to $6.6 million. Paxton dropped his appeal in July 2025, a few months after announcing his Senate campaign. So the man asking to represent Texas in the Senate stopped contesting a finding that his office fired people for reporting him to the FBI, and the state’s taxpayers are paying for it, along with roughly $1.2 million in interest if the bill goes unpaid until 2027. Paxton’s office fired the four deputies, and Texas taxpayers are paying the judgment, so none of the cost of that decision falls on Paxton himself. A senator’s job is voting on how public money gets spent, and I’d worry most about someone who has already sent the public the bill for his own conduct.

The securities case matters more to me as an investor, because the people on the other side of those deals were investors. Paxton was indicted in 2015 on felony charges that he sold securities without a license and didn’t tell buyers he was being paid to sell them. In March 2024 he agreed to a pretrial intervention deal, which meant about $271,000 in restitution to the people he allegedly misled, 100 hours of community service, and 15 hours of legal ethics training, and the charges were dismissed in 2025 once he finished. There was no admission of guilt, and Cogdell said so at the time. My read is that when someone pays back the better part of $300,000 to investors in a deal, I want that explained before I wire money, and it’s a lot to explain.

To be fair, every formal process cleared him. The Texas Senate acquitted him on all 16 articles it tried, a federal investigation ended in 2024 without charges, and Texans reelected him twice as attorney general while he was under indictment, so most of this was already in front of voters. References aren’t neutral either. Paxton’s campaign points out that Cogdell is a Democrat who voted in the 2024 Democratic primary, and that’s a fair thing to weigh. I grant all of it. A trial asks whether something can be proven, and diligence asks whether you’d trust the person with your money, and those are different bars.

Who Else Is Calling

Neil Bush, George W. Bush’s brother, posted on Tuesday that he had voted early for Talarico, in what he said was his first political post on social media, and a group of roughly 20 Republicans launched Republicans for Talarico here in Dallas.

I think Talarico has far more integrity than Paxton, and I think the kind of politics Paxton stands for is harmful, both to the people he’s supposed to serve and to the people who used to work for him. I don’t want him representing me or my state.

I’m voting early for Talarico in the next few days. Early voting runs through October 30, and Election Day is November 3. I don’t know whether a reference check moves votes the way it moves checks. In my world, when a founder’s own lawyer and former law enforcement director are backing someone else, I pass, and I think most investors would too… I guess we’ll find out whether Texas reads references the same way.